Why Sarah Palin Quit: The Five Best Explanations

Why Sarah Palin Quit: The Five Best Explanations

When Alaska Governor Sarah Palin announced her intention to resign on July 3, many assumed there must be a looming scandal. Why else make the surprise announcement late in the afternoon before the July 4 holiday — the equivalent of a news black hole — in tones that varied from angry to anxious? Palin even hauled her husband back from a commercial fishing trip to be by her side.

In the days since, however, it has become clear that no other shoe is likely to drop. No federal investigation or teen pregnancy or hikes along the Appalachian Trail. Alaskan politicos who have worked with Palin for years say her reasons for leaving are multilayered, and largely personal. Her unhappiness in the job came as no surprise in Alaska. In fact, given her history — and how miserable the past eight months have been for her — perhaps the surprise is that more people didn’t see it coming. Here are the most important factors that Alaska insiders say went into Palin’s sudden decision.

1. If It Worked Before, Why Not Try It Again

Palin’s 2004 protest resignation from the Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission catapulted her into the political limelight. Appointed to the AOGCC by then Governor Frank Murkowski, Palin quit when fellow board member Randy Ruedrich, who was also chairman of the Alaska Republican Party, refused to give up his party role despite what many saw as a conflict of interest. Palin accused Ruedrich of engaging in politics on government time, and he was ultimately fined $11,000 — the largest ethics fine in Alaska’s history. He resigned his AOGCC post . Palin was perceived as a whistle-blower, willing to call out her own party. Less than two years later, Palin won Murkowski’s job. “She was going to stand up to the corrupt administration, she was going to expose wrongdoing, she was going to slay the evil dragon,” says Larry Persily, a former Palin aide who now works for a Republican state legislator. “She knows how to position herself. She knows how to appeal to the public, and that was a great move.”

In her announcement on July 3, Palin sought to portray her resignation in much the same way: a selfless act that should earn her kudos for saving taxpayers’ money. “Many just accept that lame-duck status, hit the road, draw the paycheck and milk it. I’m not putting Alaska through that — I promised efficiencies and effectiveness,” she said. “I love my job, and I love Alaska. It hurts to make this choice, but I am doing what’s best for Alaska.”

Perhaps. But this time around, her motives don’t ring as true. “In some ways, she is trying to repeat that feat,” Persily says. “But there are some flaws in the argument. Under her thinking, every second-term governor or President was a misfit for staying in office because you can’t run for re-election. That doesn’t make sense.”

2. Bye-Bye, Bipartisanship

At the start of her term in 2006, Palin’s platform looked much more Democratic than Republican. She picked up on Dem calls for ethics reform and backed Democratic stands against oil- and gas-company interests. She made limited mention of abortion and other social-conservative issues. She would also visit the legislative offices, sometimes bringing fresh baked cookies and bagels. “I’m sure she visited some Republicans, but mostly the people she visited were Democrats,” says Alaska representative Harry Crawford, an Anchorage Democrat who has known Palin for more than a decade. “With Sarah, we were able to do things that we’d been trying to do for 25 years. Everything she can point to in terms of achievements was done with nearly uniform Democrats votes and just a smattering of Republican votes.”

But her vice-presidential candidacy remolded Palin in the eyes of Alaskan Democrats from a moderate willing to reach out across the aisle to a bomb thrower who accused Barack Obama of “palling around with terrorists.” As she became more partisan, she lost support in Alaska — her favorable poll numbers are now in the mid-50s, down from the 80s before she was tapped for VP. Without the Democrats, her agenda has gone nowhere, and she’s now attacked from both the left and the right. “I saw her on the elevator in the beginning of session in January,” Crawford says. “I said, ‘Good afternoon.’ She didn’t even reply. She was standing there six inches from me, and she didn’t say a word. We’ve hardly seen each other since. This was someone I considered a friend.”

Other legislators lay the blame at the Democrats’ door. “I believe the word came down from national Democrats to local Democrats to do everything in their power to take her down,” says state senator Gene Therriault, a Republican who represents the town of North Pole. “We started seeing a proliferation of ethics complaints against her. It was an orchestrated effort to take her down.” Either way, all sides agree that the relationship is irreparable.

See the screwups of Campaign ’08.
See 10 Sarah Palin spoofs.