The Dead Polo Ponies and Their Mysterious Millionaire Owner

The Dead Polo Ponies and Their Mysterious Millionaire Owner

Polo fans say few things are as inspiring as watching eight majestic thoroughbred horses maneuver over a 300-yard-long field. But as anyone who was at the U.S. Open polo tournament in Wellington, Fla., last Sunday has attested, few things are as shocking as seeing those same horses stagger and drop dead. Twenty-one polo ponies belonging to the Lechuza Caracas team from Venezuela died either before, during or after Lechuza’s Sunday afternoon match.

So far investigators have yet to determine exactly what killed the animals. Lechuza’s Argentine captain, Juan Martín Nero, told the Buenos Aires daily La Nación this morning he believed that tainted Biodyl, a vitamin supplement he said the team regularly gives its horses before matches to ward off exhaustion, was the culprit. “There were five [Lechuza] horses who were not given the vitamin,” Nero told La Nación, “and they’re the only ones that are fine.” Nero insisted in the interview that Biodyl is “nothing prohibited.” But he’s wrong. It turns out, the Food & Drug Administration confirms to TIME, that Biodyl has not been approved for use in the U.S.; and that if the horses were being injected with it, “it was illegal,” says an FDA spokesperson.

Still, unless the vitamin was corrupted with something especially toxic, many veterinarians doubt Biodyl alone could have caused the equine die-off. Investigators, including those examining many of the dead horses at the University of Florida’s veterinary school, say it could be days before they unravel the toxicological mystery. Florida’s state Agriculture Department announced late Wednesday afternoon that almost all the horses suffered from hemorrhaging of the lungs before they collapsed.

But whatever the cause, the tragedy has thrust Lechuza’s obscure but powerful owner, multi-millionaire Venezuelan banker and polo fanatic Victor Vargas, into the spotlight he usually avoids. In fact, since the beginning of the week, Vargas has not been seen at the Palm Beach Polo Club in Wellington; newspaper reports in the Palm Beach Post and other South Florida media say he’s either holed up in the $70 million Palm Beach mansion he purchased last year — one of six homes he owns in Venezuela, the Caribbean, the U.S. and Europe — or has flown overseas in one of his luxury Gulfstream jets.

Vargas, 57, is a hemispheric jetsetter who has successfully navigated between the often contentious relationship of Venezuela and the United States, though hardly without controversy. As a young lawyer he married into one of Venezuela’s cogollo families and then, as one of the country’s smartest bankers, learned to swim in its prodigious and often corrupt oil industry. But while many of Venezuela’s business and financial titans have chafed under the left-wing revolution Hugo Chávez began a decade ago, Vargas and his Banco Occidental de Descuento have thrived.

Critics say Vargas made a backroom deal with Chávez’s government to handle some of the revolution’s murkier financial transactions, such as more than $1 billion in Argentine bond swaps, or the handling of hard currency between Venezuela’s official exchange rate of about 2.15 bolivares to the U.S. dollar and the quasi-legal black-market rate of almost six to the dollar. Vargas has long denied the accusation, insisting he’s not part of the “boli-bourgeoisie” that got rich cozying up to Chávez while oil prices skyrocketed in recent years. He and his friends say instead that he’s simply a banker Chávez officials have found trustworthy, a man who can deal in capitalist circles but who funds three foundations for the poor and deep down sympathizes with the revolution’s social agenda.

Perhaps, but Vargas’ lifestyle is hardly the stuff of Chávez’s “21st-century socialism.” In a rare interview last year, he told the Wall Street Journal, “People write stories about me saying I have a Ferrari, a plane, a yacht. But it’s not true. I’ve got three planes, two yachts, six houses. I’ve been rich all my life!” In 2004, his daughter Margarita wed Luis Alfonso de Borbón, a cousin of Spain’s King Juan Carlos, great-grandson of the late Spanish dictator Francisco Franco and a legitimate heir to the non-existent throne of France. They were married at Vargas’ palatial mansion in the Dominican Republic, a wedding that was catered by New York’s exclusive Le Cirque restaurant and included 1,000 guests.

But although Vargas enjoys conspicuous wealth in the U.S., his banking career in the country has met obstacles. In 1993 he paid the Federal Reserve Bank of New York $1.5 million in fines after it determined Vargas had lied about his knowledge of fraud that executives had committed at a bank he was in the process of acquiring. Today, Vargas cannot invest in U.S. banks without government permission. Still, the incident doesn’t seem to have put much of a dent in his personal worth .

The high cost of caring for horses has sometimes led some owners to abandon their animals, to sell them to slaughterhouses or to attempts at fraud in order to collect insurance. But polo is a rich man’s sport and Vargas certainly does not seem to have been hurting from the care and feeding of his steeds — or skimping on providing for them. His Lechuza Caracas polo team plays around the world, and he transports his stable of 60 ponies — estimated to cost about $100,000 each — on special jets.

So what killed the animals Nero, in the La Nación interview, insisted that Lechuza would never inject performance-enhancing steroids or other similar substances into the team’s horses, not only because those substances are banned in polo-playing countries like Britain, but because “we live with them. If there’s anyone who never wants to see their horses killed, it’s us.” Meanwhile, whether or not the horses died from being injected with anything illicit, polo figures like Neil Hirsch, owner of Black Watch, one of the U.S.’s best teams, are calling now for the U.S to get more serious about anti-doping rules in equestrian sports.

Vargas has yet to weigh in himself. He is said to be devastated by the horses’ deaths; but this is hardly the worst loss he’s suffered. Some years ago, Vargas’ 18-year old son Victor, himself an accomplished polo player, died of a bacterial infection. With reporting by Virginia López/Caracas

See TIME’s Pictures of the Week.