Supreme Court rules against networks on indecent speech


The Supreme Court ruled federal regulators can stop TV networks from airing profanity.
The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that federal regulators have the authority to clamp down on broadcast TV networks that air isolated cases of profanity, known as "fleeting expletives."

The 5-4 vote was a victory for Bush-era officials who pushed fines and sanctions when racy images and language reached the airwaves. Controversial words have been aired in scripted and unscripted instances on all the major over-the-air networks in the past six years, when the Federal Communications Commission began considering a stronger, no-tolerance policy. “It suffices the new policy is permissible under the statute, there are good reasons for it, and the agency believes it to be better,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority. The high court, however, refused to decide whether the commission’s policy violates the First Amendment guarantee of free speech. It ruled only on the agency’s enforcement power. The justices ordered the free-speech aspect to be reviewed again by a federal appeals court. ABC, CBS, NBC and Fox were parties in the case. A federal appeals court in New York had ruled in their favor, calling the commission’s policy “arbitrary and capricious.” The commission then appealed to the Supreme Court, seeking restoration of its power to penalize the networks airing “indecent” speech, even if it is broadcast only one time, and even if it does not describe a specific sex act. The high court agreed to some extent. “Even when used as an expletive, the F-word’s power to insult and offend derives from its sexual meaning,” wrote Scalia.

Don’t Miss
Appeals court rejects suit over alleged Gitmo abuse

Supreme Court tackles free speech vs. animal cruelty

High court asked to untangle reverse discrimination case

Such language is heard with greater, albeit varying, frequency on cable television, the Internet, and satellite radio, which do not use public airwaves. But the federal government is charged with responding to viewer complaints when “indecent” language reaches broadcast television and radio, which is subject to greater regulation. That is especially relevant during daytime and early evening hours, when larger numbers of families and younger viewers may be watching. The communications commission formally reversed its policy in March 2004 to declare even a single use of an expletive could be illegal. The changes became known as the “Golden Globes Rule,” for singer Bono’s 2003 acceptance speech at the awards show on NBC, where he uttered the phrase “really, really, f—ing brilliant.” The commission specifically cited celebrities Cher and Nicole Richie for potty-mouth language in the 2002 and 2003 Billboard Music Awards, which aired on Fox. Richie, in an apparent scripted moment said, “Have you ever tried to get cow s–t out of a Prada purse It’s not so f—ing simple.” The complaint against ABC involved “NYPD Blue,” a now-canceled scripted police drama, and the CBS’ complaint involved “The Early Show,” a news and interview program. Enforcement of the law had been put on hold while the case was being argued. In dissent, Justice John Paul Stevens said “customs of speech” made the Federal Communications Commission’s position unworkable. “As any golfer who has watched his partner shank a short approach knows, it would be absurd to accept the suggestion that the resultant four-letter word uttered on the golf course describes sex or excrement and is therefore indecent,” he wrote. “But that is the absurdity the FCC has embraced in its new approach to indecency.” The Supreme Court first ventured into the broadcast speech debate in 1978, when it ruled as indecent a monologue by comedian George Carlin on society’s taboo surrounding “seven dirty words.” The bit had received some radio airplay. Stevens, 89, was the author of that opinion. Time Warner — the parent company of CNN — filed an amicus brief supporting the networks fined by the communications commission. The company is part owner of the CW broadcast network, and operates several cable networks.

Share