State house sculpture in ‘poor taste’

State tenants are slamming a $1.5 million sculpture proposed for Queens Wharf say it’s ironic and offensive.

The artwork designed by Michael Parekowhai is a model of a state house with a $700,000 hand-blown Venetian glass chandelier inside.

It’s two-thirds of the size of a state house and early design images leaked to media are drawing serious criticism.

Leading the charge are state house tenants under threat of eviction as Housing New Zealand sells off some of its stock. The extravagant work was commissioned after a $1 m donation from Barfoot & Thompson in 2013. A further $500,000 is needed from Auckland Council to make up the shortfall.

Westmere state tenant and artist Gael Baldock said the sculpture is in “very bad taste”.

The cost of the chandelier alone could help build two new state houses, she said.

“With the amount of homeless we have, particularly in Auckland now, the whole thing is insulting.”

Glen Innes state tenant Sue Henry said the idea is appalling.

The Housing New Zealand Northern Glen Innes redevelopment project is in full-force in her suburb, moving 156 tenants and families out in the process.

“It’s almost like a trophy for developers and real estate agents that they’ve got rid of the state houses, that’s the way I see it.”

Councillor Mike Lee says the sculpture is not in keeping with the maritime elements and history of Queens Wharf.

He said the council should scrap the project or move it elsewhere.

“There’s an irony – and the state house tenants have picked it up perfectly. There are a lot of state house tenants being evicted in Auckland right now. It seems to be in poor taste . . . especially when we’re trying to reconfigure our budget to reduce rates increases.”

Waitemata Local Board chairman Shale Chambers says donations for public art should be encouraged but the scale and site planned for this piece are not appropriate.

“The issue is the scale, which clearly has an impact in terms of site plans and views to the harbour. Is it the right place to put it at that scale”

Councillor Cathy Casey said she voted against the sculpture in an Arts, Culture and Events Committee meeting on June 18, largely because of the cost of the chandelier and the chosen site.

“It’s a hugely generous offer, I just wish we had capped it in our brief. What did we say in our brief to the artist I don’t support secrecy. I want everything out on the table – we need to put all those questions to the art team and to the artists.”

Orakei councillor Cameron Brewer said the subject of the work is controversial but his “big beef” is with the ratepayer contribution.

“If we can’t get a fabulous sculpture on Queens Wharf for less than $1m of privately funded money we should forget about it,” Brewer said.

“Let’s stick to the budget. Let’s not throw ratepayer money on top.”

Auckland Council Art and Culture manager Kaye Glamuzina says the artist has not completed designs for the sculpture but they will be made public when ready. The cost is consistent with other public art projects in recent years, Glamuzina said.

Ad Feedback

The sculpture will be a wharf “lighthouse” to signify a safe harbour and welcome, she said.

Artist Michael Parekowhai said the project is not at a point where he can comment.

– East And Bays Courier


Star Wars to have fewer CGI effects

The next Continue reading


Taylor Swift shakes off negativity

Taylor Swift has learned an invaluable lesson: when life kicks you down sometimes you’ve just got to dance. Like many pop stars before her, Swift has penned an anthem, Shake it Off, to busting a move Continue reading


Lorde brings album tour home

Of her first New Zealand tour since becoming a megastar, Lorde has three words: ‘‘I’m so excited.’’ Continue reading


Drug crackdown snares Jackie Chan’s son

Hong Kong action superstar Jackie Chan’s actor-son Jaycee Chan has been detained in Beijing on drug-related charges, the latest high-profile celebrity to be ensnared in one of China’s biggest anti-drug crackdowns in two decades. Jaycee Chan, 32, was detained last Thursday together with the 23-year-old Taiwanese movie star Kai Ko, Beijing police said yesterday on their official microblog, identifying them only by their surnames, ages and nationalities. Continue reading


Funniest Edinburgh Fringe joke ‘sucks’

A joke about a vacuum cleaner has been voted the funniest joke at the Edinburgh Fringe comedy festival. Comedian Tim Vine dusted off his joke book to come up with a one-liner voted best wisecrack of the festival, PA reported Continue reading


Christina Aguilera called her daughter what?

Christina Aguilera and her fiance, Matt Rutler, have welcomed their daughter into the world and named her Summer Rain Rutler. The singer gave birth to baby Summer on August 16 via C-section at the Cedars-Sinai Medical Centre in Los Angeles, according to Continue reading


This is the best joke of the Edinburgh Fringe

A joke about a vacuum cleaner has been voted the funniest joke at the Edinburgh Fringe comedy festival. Comedian Tim Vine dusted off his joke book to come up with a one-liner voted best wisecrack of the festival, PA reported Continue reading


Red Nose Day: Bad language for a good cause

Cure Kids ambassador Oliver has teamed with comedian Guy Williams for this year’s Continue reading


Robin Williams video goes global

Robin Williams’ final message of hope to terminally ill North Auckland woman Vivian Waller has hit headlines across the world. The story about the 21-year-old receiving a short personal message from the late actor has been featured on television and radio stations, as well as headlines in the United States, UK, Germany, Scotland, Argentina, Canada, France, Lebanon and the Netherlands. Continue reading